Allen’s Answers

You Be the Judge: Are Your Pants Worth Millions?

  • November 16, 2018
  • LawCall
  • Comments Off on You Be the Judge: Are Your Pants Worth Millions?

$67 million pants?

What do you think is fair if a business loses your property?

FACTS:

A dry cleaner returned a pair of pants. The owner of the pants claimed they were not his pants. He sued for $67 million dollars. The biggest piece of evidence was a sign that hung in the dry cleaner’s window that stated, “Satisfaction Guaranteed.” It didn’t help that the customer was a judge. This is a real case from Washington, D.C.

POSSIBLE ARGUMENTS:

-It was his favorite pair of pants and had sentimental value that could not be replaced?

-The shop owner was negligent. He should have a system that tracked the pants, so they could not get lost.

-How would a jury value pants that make the owner look especially good?

-You take a risk when you leave any of your possessions with someone else. Mistakes happen it is part of life.

-The “guarantee” only covers the cost of the cleaning. Not the cost of new pants.

-If the value of the pants needs to be set, it should be for used pants.

WHAT WOULD YOU DECIDE?

ACTUAL RESULTS:

The customer was actually awarded $53 million. This was mostly for common law fraud violations and not the cost of the pants. However, the customer eventually lost the case because he could not prove the trousers that he received were not his.

Cases can be tricky. We want to help. If you are hurt in a traffic accident or suffer a personal injury, you can talk to us at the Law Firm of Eiland and Ritchie for free. We want to help you get back on your feet.

Also join us on NBC 15 LawCall here in Mobile every Sunday night at 10:30 right after the news. We do a short show on tape during the football season but will take your calls live again after the first of the year.

Allen Ritchie

Alabama personal injury lawyer

Comments are closed.